Agent Vendor & Tool Evaluation Rubric
Score any AI agent product or MCP server before you buy: build a weighted criteria model, separate verified facts from vendor claims, produce a scored Adopt/Pilot/Hold/Reject verdict, and rank the open risks into a procurement action plan. Works in any chat model — no connected tools needed.
A 4-step agentic workflow pack for coding built to run with ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini. Open the Markdown files, fill the variables, and paste into your model. Most buyers get a reviewable result in about 60 minutes.
- Turn a vague 'which agent tool should we buy' question into a weighted, defensible scoring model in one pass
- Separate independently verified facts from vendor marketing claims so demos and datasheets never drive the decision
- Score every candidate on capability, security posture, lock-in, cost curve, reliability, and vendor viability with explicit 1-5 anchors
- Get an Adopt / Pilot / Hold / Reject verdict with confidence levels and hard security gates that cap a weak candidate regardless of its total
- Generate the exact due-diligence questions to send each vendor to close every evidence gap before you sign
- Rank open risks by exposure and effort into an owned, dated procurement action plan with blocker and pilot gates
- Works in any chat model (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini) with no connected tools — paste vendor docs and eval notes, get structured decision artifacts back
Prompt Customization Service — optional help adapting variables and output to your brand voice. Choose your tier at checkout (not tied to this prompt's price).
This pack is $10 on its own. Buying every pack separately costs $1167. The Lifetime Bundle is $149 one-time — you save $1018 (87% off) and unlock every future pack free.
Get the Lifetime Bundle — $149Paste the license key from your receipt. It must match this prompt pack.
What ships with your purchase
Prompt files
Plain Markdown files with `{{variables}}` you fill in, ready to paste into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. No setup, no tooling required.
Usage guide
Variable reference, model compatibility, examples, and customization tips so you can adapt the pack to your brand voice.
Lifetime updates
When we improve the pack, you get the new version automatically. Email support included with every purchase.
Models tested: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini.
The workflow inside this pack
4 composable prompts you run in order — each one picks up where the last left off.
- Step 1
Scope & Criteria Builder
Paste your shortlist of candidate agent products or MCP servers, describe the job you need them to do, and list your hard constraints (budget, compliance, must-integrate systems)
- Step 2
Evidence Interrogator
Paste the criteria model from the Scope & Criteria Builder plus everything you have gathered on one candidate — marketing copy, docs, security page, MCP README, benchmark reports, trial notes
- Step 3
Scored Findings Report
Paste the weighted criteria model from the Scope & Criteria Builder and the graded claim register from the Evidence Interrogator for each candidate
- Step 4 · optional
Remediation Prioritizer
Paste the scored findings and verdict from the Scored Findings Report and name your target decision date
Perpetual (lifetime) use license
Your one-time purchase includes an ongoing right to use this prompt pack with the AI tools and models you control for your own and your clients' work — not for resale or public redistribution of the files as a product.
We keep the copyright
The prompt files, guides, examples, and bundled assets stay our copyrighted works (or our licensors'). Payment grants the limited license in our Terms only — it does not transfer ownership.
Need help adapting this prompt to your team? Add Prompt Customization Service at checkout.